["if you're advocating the systematic elimination of a certain race (in this case Jews) then I'd say you're racist."]
im just trying to save lives dude, killing jews is the best thing we can do, if we dont kill them NOW, then they WILL do it in the future, to our children.. if you want your race got killed by some jews, then whatever, go ahead
47 comments
If you identify yourself by a "race", you are a racist.
If you consider "race" to be a valid and meaningfull concept, you are a racist.
Killing jews wont save lives.
If you advocate killing jews based on the idea that jews are likely to kill you unless you get them first.... you are just short sighted and stupid.
While judaism is a racist and genocidal cult, and long overdue for reform of its core racial doctrines... IT CAN BE REFORMED!
In addition most jews do not take their religion very seriously. Some even admit that there is no jewish race.
I call that a good start... and that start came from the jewish comunity itself.
So judaism is already reforming itself without any outside help.
Your problems are gonna be these three:
1) Bullets cost money.
2)Trying to kill off all the jews is gonna make their genocidal orthodox minority quite popular with the mainstream. Thus causing otherwise peacefull jews to take up arms as well.
3) How do you even identify who is and isnt a jew? They mostly all look like average pale skinned europeans. They ARE mostly pale skinned europeans.
Most jews are what is called "white". Unless you plan on killing all white folks, you wont be able to get all the jews.
While judaism is a racist and genocidal cult, and long overdue for reform of its core racial doctrines
Next entry on RSTDT will be provided by D Laurier.
Judaism is a religion, you dimbulb! Its members are as ethnically diverse as Muslims, Buddhists, Catholics or Protestants.
19th Century thinking is all fine and retro, if you're into that sort of thing, but fuck if I'd take it seriously in the 21st Century.
D Laurier
How are jews a "Racist and Genecidal cult"? Is it because of their early history? Or maybe it's because of their scriptures. Either way, most Jews don't take them seriously. Besides, the Torah is in the bible and the Qu'ran and is part of the collective history of Muslims and Christians as well.
As to OP,
take your meds.
Maybe D Laurier is slightly excessive in his arguments, but how is wanting Israel to remain a jewish state anything but racist? Just the same as some Stormfront guy saying that America should stay white?
I don't buy Meir Kahane's sophistry that such a doctrine is not Hitlerian just because a person can become jewish.
@MTGCostello
Their early history and the fact that their holy laws still reflect the same bronze age mentality today. Also the fact that the few ultra-orthodox monsters in their midst are able to use those holy laws to justify some rather barbaric practices.
If you had read my whole reply, you would have seen that I had already indicated that most of them no longer take those laws seriously.
And yes I kinda noticed that chistianity, and islam, are both derived from judaism. And that the Q'ran is heavily plagerized from the torah and talmud. Kinda goes with being an observer of the world around me.
The derived cults are every bit as nasty in their holy laws... The difference being that (as I pointed out) judaism is reforming itself, while christianity and islam are not.
All religions have poisonous doctrines, comes with being thousands of years old!
The problem is when members of the religion decide not to ignore passages that are irrelevant and outdated.
There are far more Christians and Muslims doing that than Jews, so in terms of religious nastiness Judaism is pretty low down the scale!
London Jew, I wasn't calling you a Kahanist, nor was I even talking directly to you.
All that stuff you say is true, but I will also say that you don't have to be a Kahanist to believe that Israel should remain a jewish state.
And lest someone ask "What's wrong with ensuring that Israel remain a jewish state," well think about it, what way could such a thing be maintained without some sort of discrimination or other distasteful practice (such as trying to outbreed the arabs)?
I love the reasoning (so to speak) that he uses to justify this. Because people have been killing Jews for thousands of years, the Jews want to kill everyone else in the world. Therefore, to keep the Jews from killing everyone, we need to kill more Jews! I think I see a minor logical flaw in his argument right there.
FSTDT has a picture of this guy!
image
"I am teh wargaming hitlerz, beware my painted Warhammer stormtrooperz of doom!"
I just want you to shut the fuck up dude, killing you is the best thing we can do, if we don't kill you NOW, then you WILL annoy the hell out of us in the future, our children... if you want normal people got pissed off by some bigot, then whatever, go ahead.
"Trying to outbreed the arabs"
Err... Semitic Jews and 'arabs' (I assume you mean Semitic Muslims) are genetically the same people.
Jews are not a race, but two races are generally associated with Judaism: The Semites, typically called Israelis, and the European 'Ashkenazi' Jews - often just called 'Yiddish'.
Depending on which one you're thinking of, you could play host to a totally different group of pointless slurs and stereotypes.
Y'know who else liked killing Jews? Hitler.
Go ahead, OP. I dare you to try it and not expect to get into deep with the police.
@D Laurier:
I am told that races are valid constructs in certain contexts, eg, speciation. Does that make the people who told me that racists?
Also, a gens is similar to a race; hypothetically speaking, would discrimination based on gens be considered racist, or would I need a new word to describe it?
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.