Amos Moses #fundie disqus.com
Amos Moses:
CONSENT IS IRRELEVANT when a 12-13 year old can consent to just about anything ......... IRRELEVANT ........ "You don't even know what my worldview IS. " ....and you have argued here long enough for your views to be known ....... JUST as you have made it known right now on this topic ......... so stick that in your ear ........... you have plainly said you are an "agnostic atheist" ...... and more than once .......
TheKingOfRhye:
Okay then....answer me this question: Why is rape bad? (if you think it is bad, that is....I can't too be around sure sometimes)
Amos Moses:
YOU answer why rape is bad ..... as an "agnostic atheist" you have absolutely no basis to say it is good or bad or evil or vile or wonderful or any other thing ...... you have NO OBJECTIVE MORALITY to even say one thing about it ....... except that YOUR PERSONAL OPINION is that you do not like it ....... and that is about it .......... only YOUR OPINION ..... no OBJECTIVE STANDARD ......
TheKingOfRhye:
Nuh-uh. I asked you the question. If you can't answer a simple question, there's no point in having this conversation.
Amos Moses:
NOPE ..... you CANNOT EVEN GET to a charge of "rape" as you have no OBJECTIVE MORALITY to even come to a conclusion that a "rape" even EVER occurred EVER ........... PROVE that anything whatsoever is "rape" ...... you claim "rape" ..... PROVE YOUR CLAIM ...... but according to an "agnostic"view that probably is "unknowable" ..... and from an "atheistic" point of view it is just this bit of biological protoplasm doing something to ANOTHER bit of biological protoplasm and you do not like it ......... and it is JUST YOUR OPINION ............ "rape" requires a MORAL judgement ..... and YOU have ABANDONED that ..........
TheKingOfRhye:
So, yeah....you're basically telling me you need your god to tell you that rape is wrong, which is pretty much where I thought you were gonna go.