Man spreads HIV to over 2 dozen partners http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...g-friends.html
It is the person's responsibility to ask and make sure their partner is healthy. A person with HIV does not have the obligation to reveal their medical history to someone.
This man should not go to jail.
12 comments
The OP trips and falls onto tall grass/a bush. He finds - painfully - sticking out of his arm/leg a used syringe thrown away in such a public place.
Walking barefoot on the beach, he treads - painfully - onto a used syringe left in the sand: where children play.
It is the OP's responsibility to make sure that the entire area they are about to enter is free from such bio hazards. A person with HIV from dirty needles does not have the obligation to put their used syringes in the proper receptacle.
The latter person should not go to jail.
...and now you see where your entire 'argument' fails?
Watch where you walk, AHUGEPRATT.
But there's a limit to how many questions you can ask your partner.
If a person KNOWS something may pose a risk to their partner, it's THEIR duty to share this information. They don't have to share their entire medical, mental, social history, but it is THEIR fault if they bring harm to another.
Person A meets Person B
Person A buys Person B a drink
Person A sets intensive interview process for person B
Upon receipt of test results
Sure, you might have responsibility to ask, but you have much, much more responsibility to actually TELL when you know you're not healthy.
This man should go to jail. One partner might be a mistake, two dozen is deliberate abuse.
Yes. They do. Full stop. "You never asked" is not a valid defense for why you didn't tell your partner that you have a horrible, incurable, life-altering disease. Life isn't a fucking comedy sketch (hard as that is to believe with fools like yourself on the stage).
Putting aside the fact that, Yes, he DOES have that responsibility, there's nothing in that story that indicated that they DIDN'T ask. How do we know that they didn't ask him, and he just lied to their faces?
Who goes to jail then?
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.
