You are simply telling kids that the current 'beliefs' of a bunch of scientist are fact. Just because you spent 10 years in college does not make your personal belief any more right that any one else.
17 comments
See, kids, this is where deconstructionism goes bad. People interpret it to mean, "LOL, the half-baked ignorant notion of any slack-jawed yokel is of equal merit to the detailed theory of intelligent, well-informed experts who have dedicated their life to a field!"
There are "subjective" things about which one can have opinions, such as whether a band is "good," whether broccoli is yummy, or whether premarital sex is immoral. And then there are "objective" things, which can have a factual answer, and about which one can indeed be incorrect, such as "The sky is made of lemonade," "Dinosaurs and humans co-existed," and "Evolution does not occur."
Tommy (Chris Farley): Did you hear I finally graduated?
Richard (David Spade): Yeah, and just a shade under a decade too, all right.
Tommy: You know a lot of people go to college for seven years.
Richard: I know, they're called doctors.
So you're saying that Unky Clem, the turnip truck driver with a 2nd grade education, has an equally valid opinion on astrophysics and microbiology as, say, an astronomer and a microbiologist?
I recommend that if you every need surgery you look up Unky Clem instead of a doctor. I'm sure Unky Clem will do just as well. After all, that doctor was stupid enough to spend years and years in college and medical school.
Where that "personal belief" has to do with one's professional understanding of facts and their proper interpretation, yes, it does make it much more "right." Education, training, and experience constitute a foundation for having such "beliefs"; ignorance, avoidance, and stubbornness do not.
These are not "personal beliefs" on par with "beliefs" of faith, interest, or taste. These are PROFESSIONAL INTERPRETATIONS OF EVIDENCE derived from education, training, and experience in highly technical fields. Their conclusions may safely be treated as fact -- provisional fact where the details are concerned, and absolute fact, as much as gravity, where the general principles are concerned.
~David D.G.
Hey "the girl with shit on the face",
Scientific theories are based on objective evidence and peer review. They are not 'beliefs'. Personal beliefs are based on an individuals view of the world and have no value other than to that individual (or maybe for mockery by others as I am doing to yours). Scientist know the difference, uneducated people usually don't.
ARRRRRRG! I am sick of this particular brand of idiocy.
"Hey, don't you be talkin' 'bout none of that book learnin'. I don't go fur none o' that!"
Fine, then be prepared to be called a moron you slack-jawed hick!
actually yes, I will believe the opinions of those who have spent ten years studying science over random people who haven't. Because you know, maybe the people who have spent ten years studying this stuff know what the fuck they are talking about?
Sounds like my ex. "You can't just say one thing is right and another thing is wrong. You don't know ."
Never could get over the idiocy. Is ice cream cold? Are you human? Is pain unpleasant? Do objects fall if released midair? well hao du yu no hur durr
> Just because you spent 10 years in college does not make your personal belief any more right that any one else.
It means you know more than the average person about that thing you spent ten years studying. No more (stupid know-it-all doctors who think they know more about computers than I do) and no less (stupid preachers who think they know more about physics than Stephen Hawking).
“You are simply telling kids that the current 'beliefs' of a bunch of scientist are fact.”
Homeschooled, huh?
In schools, they get the current theories, AND the explanations for how they came to be the current theories, often including ‘experiments you can do yourself’ to back up the theories.
We do NOT just say, “Scientists took a vote and decided this shit was realio-trulio.”
" Just because you spent 10 years in college does not make your personal belief any more right that any one else.”
Actually, experts are experts BECAUSE the stuff they know is more know than drooling idiots can come up with. For example, thinking that the science that’s taught (or the math, or the history, or the politics) is just a list of beliefs.That’s stupid-wrong.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.