[A Birmingham pastor and his congregation build a church without getting any building permits or following any building codes and, surprise, the church collapses. The pastor then remarks:]
If the state and the church are separate, I don't understand why they think they've got jurisdiction.
Thank God nobody was hurt. He chose to let it come down on a Thursday evening when nobody was there.
35 comments
They have jurisdiction because, *gasp*, you're in their jurisdiction! By living in this country, you must live under our laws. That's just how it is, fucktard.
Follow some logic with your own bizarre religious postulates.
1) You put the church up without getting any state approval.
2) The church falls down without any intervention, meaning God must've wanted it that way.
3) God and the state agree, which is WHY the state gets jurisdiction.
Or, y'know, you could just say the state knows BETTER than you do and would've helped you put up a better quality code-adhering church and the stupid thing might NOT have fallen down... but no, that doesn't give you an excuse to praise god again, does it?
"If the state and the church are separate, I don't understand why they think they've got jurisdiction."
Because even your congregation members are citizens of this country.
Kent Hovind tried this schtick, too.
"Thank God nobody was hurt. He chose to let it come down on a Thursday evening when nobody was there."
If indeed "God" caused your church to fall down, doesn't that tell you something? Maybe "God" doesn't like you. Maybe "God's" an asshole. I don't think it was really "God" who cause the collapse as "God" would have to exist for that.
Churches are not granted extraterritoriality. Activities taking place within the space of a church must still be in line with state laws. That means you can't have an unliscenced boxing match in a church, you can't sell heroin in a church and you can't build the walls out of paper mache, coat hangers and hot glue in a church either.
You see, it's not a matter of the first amendment, or even politics in general. It's a matter of safety , a rather novel concept that's easy enough to follow.
Oh, that's right, you got the LAWD to protect y'all.
Note to Jezebel's sister (#68970).
This Christian agrees with you completely . Many churches, particularly the larger ones, are run much like corporations with their deacons/elders/associate pastors functioning very much like a board of directors.
These churches make absolutely no bones about actively supporting political candidates and promoting political causes.
Many of these churches are multi-million dollar structures and some actually have bank branches and small restaurants within them; and their ministers receive very healthy salaries with significant perks.
If these churches want to endorse politicians, become involved in politics and function as corporations by God they can pay taxes like corporations and I support your comment 100 percent!
Note to Jezebel's sister (#68970).
This Christian agrees with you completely . Many churches, particularly the larger ones, are run much like corporations with their deacons/elders/associate pastors functioning very much like a board of directors.
These churches make absolutely no bones about actively supporting political candidates and promoting political causes.
Many of these churches are multi-million dollar structures and some actually have bank branches and small restaurants within them; and their ministers receive very healthy salaries with significant perks.
If these churches want to endorse politicians, become involved in politics and function as corporations by God they can pay taxes like corporations and I support your comment 100 percent!
Reminds me of Terry Pratchet's description of the Lady Luck, and whether or not she's an actual goddess - after all, you get nothing for praying to her, and any temples built in her name are almost certain to fall down.
"If the state and the church are separate, I don't understand why they think they've got jurisdiction."
So idiots like you don't kill people.
"Thank God nobody was hurt. He chose to let it come down on a Thursday evening when nobody was there."
Still not grasping the concept. If you want your buildings to stand,
you have to use science.
UberLutherian said: "Many of these churches are multi-million dollar structures and some actually have bank branches and small restaurants within them; and their ministers receive very healthy salaries with significant perks."
Wait, bank branches? I seem to remember a story about moneylenders being driven from the temple. Huh.
Randola said: "Why is God never blamed for the bad things?"
I was just having the same conversation with a friend last weekend. Hypothetical situation: A plane crashes in the mountains and 205 people die, and three survive with injuries and burns. Fundie say: "Praise god those people made it! What a miracle!"
Me say: "Hey, if god is so good, how come 205 people are being pieced together and shipped to their hometown in black bags? That's what you call a miracle? Why did it crash in the first place? Wouldn't a REAL miracle include something like landing the plane without any wings or something? I fumigated my garage but I still found three half-dead bugs near the window. IT'S A MIRACLE!
What's truly a miracle is that your law-skirting didn't kill or maim anybody. That's why you have to obtain a building permit, so jackasses like yourself don't get a bunch of backyard mechanics together to slap a church together.
You sir, are a dipshit.
"If the state and the church are separate, I don't understand why they think they've got jurisdiction."
The state and church aren't separate. The constitution just says the government may not establish a religion ("establish" in this context means to give official status to or recognize as true or valid). Churches don't have "diplomatic immunity" from our laws.
This is such a wonderful story. A pastor ignores building codes, builds a church incompetently, then praises God for the wonderful miracle when it falls apart. Later in the article, he goes on to claim that the state should let churches flout safety laws right after his church collapsed because he broke safety laws. In the end, he said that he started with faith, and still has it.
Actually, that's a good metaphor there a building built on faith alone can't stand. Literally.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.