God does not allow things to pass outside of his will. There is not a randomness to what happens in the world. Sure, we are accountable for what we do, but it doesnt take away the fact that God is still in control. Sounds paradoxical doesnt it? But, its more like "Why is grass green?" It just is. God just is. Gods ways just are. Seems unfair? Nope, God is God and knows what hes doing. This is an aspect of faith. You trust what God is doing even if it seems wrong. Is that foolish? Blind faith? Nope, God gives you so much proof of himself as you grow in your relationship with him, that it is not blind at all. [Emphasis added.]
53 comments
Sorry you lose; grass is green because the light absorption of the color green is just right for photosynthetic organisms to absorb the type of energy they need to convert CO2 and water into energy. For all of you that answered Goddunit, you fail, thank you for playing.
Guys, remember that red and blue chlorophyll do exist. They just happen to be rarer, because...well...they aren't as efficient. Grass could be blue or red, it just happens to be green because green is the most effective color.
"God just is" is simply an intellectual cop-out on the same order as "Goddidit." You can't explain it so you opt for the simple, non-explanation of "God just is."
Grass and most other plants have evolved to be green for efficient conversion of sunlight into food by way of chlorophyll. If some other mechanism of some other color had worked significantly better, most plants would be that color.
When I was growing up, the grass question came up among kids and we had to be satisfied with this sort of cop-out answer. Same with, 'Why is the sky blue?' or 'how far away is heaven?'
Guess what? There are answers to all of them. Just because the people I asked didn't know, didn't make the questions unanswerable. They didn't know so they gave me a bit of fluff and expected I'd be happy with that.
So all of these god mysteries are now explainable. If I hadn't been told that an invisable man did it, and just been told they didn't know, maybe I wouldn't of (rightly so) denied the god angle on the grounds that there is nothing left that can be attributed to 'him'. Just because we don't immediately know an answer doesn't mean it was magic, it just means we haven't cracked it yet. That doesn't prove the existance of jack shit.
God is God
WOW! That explains everything. [/sarcasm]
God gives you so much proof of himself as you grow in your relationship with him...
He does? Where?Shouldn't he give you more of this so-called "proof" right at the beginning when you doubt the most?
Sure, we are accountable for what we do, but it doesnt take away the fact that God is still in control. Sounds paradoxical doesnt it?
Yeah, it does. It sounds absolutely bonkers.I am accountable for my actions even though something else other than me is controlling them. Well done. You just failed rudimentary logic.
NotMe has a point. How do you grow a relationship with a invisible grand daddy that no-one has ever seen?
I know I did, as a child, but then again, I thought I built a relationship with a cow as I walked through our cow barn. But that relationship came to an sudden end when this cow hit me with its horns. Phew! I can say I never fainted because of a relationship with god, but from being hit by a cow.
Pointless? Yes, but Ben has no point, too.
Let´s put it clear. You are responsible FOR VIRTUALLY ANYTHING YOU DO. Otherwise, stop saying that we are making God angry and the such. If he is in control, as you claim, atheism should be the will of God. Or what?, why are you so preachy then?
This is absolutely desperate bullshit. Ben's trying to convince himself, not his audience. He's devoted himself to this belief system, and the cracks are showing. Bet you in a couple of years that Ben will renounce his faith and become an atheist.
"The puppet has free will, but the puppeteer is in control." (If he's a puppet under the control of the puppeteer, how does he have free will?)
"The player has free will, but the referee is in control." (If the referee is actually in control, how is it that the player still has free will?)
Do these comparisons make any clearer how insane this claim is?
~David D.G.
If the referee is in control, how is it that the player still has free will?
Kansas City started asking themselves that after the first game of the season.
--GF
Puppeteer analogy is much better for what you're shooting at than player/referee. The player can do whatever the hell he wants, the referee is there to impose extra consequences.
"God gives you so much proof of himself as you grow in your relationship with him ..."
Apparently, Ben doesn't have much of a relationship with the god guy because he can't pass on one molecule of proof, not even hearsay. Yeah, this could be a future atheist in the making.
Glazius #101738
<< Puppeteer analogy is much better for what you're shooting at than player/referee. The player can do whatever the hell he wants, the referee is there to impose extra consequences. >>
Glazius, the point is that the puppeteer analogy emphasizes the control position, and the player analogy emphasizes the free-will position. The referee can impose all the penalties he likes, but he cannot truly control the player, or there would be no need for penalties in the first place.
~David D.G.
You know, thinkgs are happening at such breakneck speed these days (look at the news) Knowledge is being increased, prohesy is being fulfilled. The book of Daniel...My God, The Book of Daniel!!!
God's no fool. Science is sound. God Exists!!!
Closing time soon....Get on your knees...Excused me I think I'm Saved.
yep! I'm gonna make it. Are you???
anevilmeme, quantum mechanics is far less random than it appears to be at first. The waveform equations for hydrogen have already been perfectly computed, and they're working hard on helium, which is actually an order of magnitude more complex. The Uncertainty Principle's effects can be scaled down so low that individual electrons can actually be traced.
I figure that in a decade or so, a mathematical chemistry will exist, allowing an appropriately qualified person to design materials and accurately predict all traits, qualities, and manufacturing techniques without even having set foot in a lab.
Machine translations are imperfect. Single-tired-person translations may be equally flawed. Fundiebabble-to-English translator now engaged.
Translation:
God has absolute control over the universe. Nothing happens unless God wants it to happen, but you can make things happen when God doesn't want them to happen anyway. This is obviously false by definition, but it's true. It just is! See, you can tell it's true because I don't know exactly why grass is green! Therefore, God exists. You also have to believe that God's actions are good no matter what. If you believe this, then he'll prove it, but you have to believe first.
"Why is grass green?"
Chlorophyll. Next question. Gaps. The more they're filled, the less relevance a 'God' has in peoples' lives. One of the first gaps filled was when a church put up a lightning conductor.
A question for you Ben: Why can't God appear in front of people? (check one):
[ ] Because if he did, it would result in the destruction of religion ('Proof denies faith, and without faith there can be no belief', and all that jazz).
[ ] Because he doesn't exist.
Choose wisely, Ben.
"God is God and knows what hes doing"
But he couldn't see those Iron Chariots coming (Judges 1:19). So just as Kryptonite is to Superman, Iron is to God, eh? Steel - used in the construction of vehicles - contains iron.
If 'God is in control' as you claim, then why couldn't he have done something about said chariots - as in not allow the creation of the element Iron (Fe) in the first place? There's a fuckload of Iron Chariots today eh, Ben?:
image
>:D
"God does not allow things to pass outside of his will."
Who created Lucifer , again? Please remind me Benny-boy...?:
Isiah 45:7: 'I form the light, and create darkness : I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things. '
Amos 3:6: 'Does the trumpet alarm sound in a city, without the people being afraid? Does evil happen to a city, and Yahweh hasn't done it? '
Can you say 'Omniscience ' o fundies? I know you can.
image
God: 2,038,344
Satan (and only on God's authorisation ): 10
Thanks for the great advertisement for Satanism, fundies. And for proving that Lucifer is actually the good guy in all of this.
If 'God made everything ' as you lot claim, then he made me an Atheist. Who are you to question his will ?! [/hyper-smartarse] >:D
God does not allow things to pass outside of his will.
Except the time when Lucifer told God to go fuck himself... and then when he crapped on that whole Adam-&-Eve thing that God was doing, like some beach bully who waits for you to finish your sand castle and then kicks it down... and then that thing with Cain & Able. As a matter of fact, the entire history of the Abrahamic faith is littered with Satan bullying God... and God being a non-confrontational, passive-aggressive bitch, taking it out on humanity time and time again, like the cowardly wife of a physically abusive husband, who takes her angst out on the kids by beating them. Honestly, <Sean Connery> your religion sucks balls... donkey balls. </Sean Connery>
@ Andromeda
Its been seven years now. Have you made it yet?
Oh wait, don't tell me, soon, right?
"God does not allow things to pass outside of his will. "
So it's his will that children are raped by priests they trust? And that they are born with horrible defects and cancer? And that some don't have enough to eat?
Some all-loving god that is....
"...God is God and knows what hes doing. This is an aspect of faith."
- Ah, so its all about faith then.
"God gives you so much proof of himself as you grow in your relationship with him, that it is not blind at all."
- Oh, so its not about faith, its about proof.
You seem a bit confused Ben.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.