The BANNED tonymarini & Miles Tugo #fundie washingtontimes.com

[A federal judge ruled that two undocumented immigrants have the right to abortions.]

Miles Tugo:
Illegal aliens don't have rights under the Constitution.

Rushabh Parikh:
Yeah they do. Not only does the constitution gives them rights but so does the U.N.

The BANNED tonymarini:
Uh...the Constitution applies to CITIZENS. And the UN has no authority to “give” anyone anything within the borders of the United States of America.

Ambulance Chaser:
Yes, it apply to citizens, and anyone else within the US.

The BANNED tonymarini:
No, Article 4 covers this quite well. You must be a CITIZEN (not a resident or a guest) of a State to have rights in all the others...and in the USA. Period.

Ambulance Chaser:
No, Art IV says if you’re a citizen of one state, you get to carry your rights from that state to any other state. It doesn’t say anything about constitutional rights not belonging to foreigners.

The BANNED tonymarini:
I'll type this S-L-O-W-L-Y so even you can understand. You have to be a CITIZEN of a State in the Union to be accorded rights that are transferable to other States. If you are NOT a CITIZEN of any State, you have no rights. Why else do you think that foreigners can be deported???? They are in this country as a courtesy, and have the right to due process and whatever reciprocal agreement we have with their country of origin, but little else because they are NOT CITIZENS. Regardless of what the Constitution-phobic liberals may spout on this subject.

Ambulance Chaser:

They are in this country as a courtesy and have the right to due process

Maybe the part that you should type slowly is that. Thank you for proving my point for me. I rest my case.

The BANNED tonymarini:
I guess I didn't type slowly enough.

Due process is NOT Constitutional rights. Constitutional rights only exist and flow to those for which the Constitution applies...CITIZENS.

BOOM.

Ambulance Chaser:
Wow. Due process is not a Constitutional right? You’d better reread the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.

The BANNED tonymarini:
You're being purposely obtuse. I can't debate/argue with the obtuse...there's no sense in it.

I'm out...you're on your own, Spanky.

10 comments

Confused?

So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!

To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register. Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.