Hi atheist, I have a question for you, If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible, then what could possibly prove it, or show us good evidence of it?
20 comments
I really hate ambiguities... It looks like we're assuming evolution to be false. Are we then trying to demonstrate it to be true, regardless, or false?
If we're trying to show it to be true, well, you can't (at least not honestly). But falsifying it would be trivial--if the fossil record were out of order, if our genes showed no common descent, if experiments failed to produce evolved creatures, etc.
"If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible,"
It isn't. You start with a false premise. You write like a 3rd grader.
And your basis for believing that evolution is "false, stupid, and impossible" is?
...It's been seven years since you posted your comment. I'm waiting...
"Hi atheist, I have a question for you, If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible, then what could possibly prove it, or show us good evidence of it?"
Go visit the Natural History Museum in London. Or crack open "On the Origin of Species" by Charles Darwin and "The Greatest Show On Earth: The Evidence For Evolution" by Richard Dawkins. Next question.
But a question for you, Itiswritten:
If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible, then how can a man made from dirt, a woman cloned from said dirt-man's rib, and a talking snake, as described in a certain book of fairytales, be any more credible than the facts of Evolution?
What could possibly prove it, or show us good evidence of it? And remember:
image
"Hi atheist, I have a question for you, If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible, then what could possibly prove it, or show us good evidence of it?"
Erm ... oh yes, I know.
EVIDENCE.
I think this is the third time I've typed in:
It's easily the 50th time I've seen this seeking of wisdom from us that you will ignore or freak out about.
The only stupid thing here is the question. Seeing as evolution is not false, stupid or impossible, the question is idiotic.
Not that one finds this very surprising, but still.
Evolution isn't false, stupid and impossible. There are mountains of evidence for it, and as for all other scientific theories, there is falsifiability established for it.
I have a question for you; what does atheism have to do with biology? Why ask us atheists, and not someone with a doctorate in Biology?
"If evolution is false, and stupid, and impossible, then what could possibly prove it, or show us good evidence of it?"
Well, the usual 'evidence' put forward for false, stupid, impossible claims is some sort of bible...
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.
