"the supernatural is very real."
And as you lot maintain, your 'God' is supernatural. So, going by your logic, then...:
"We can hear it, feel it, and see it."
Unless your 'God' is prepared to appear to us - even as the stereotypical image (old man, beard, white robes etc; even the size of Galactus), or at least as Morgan Freeman (a black God would be cool - just as in the films, played by said actor), then you've just destroyed your own argument. Oh, and speaking of going by your logic, SisterChicks...:
Haruhi Suzumiya. Eternal Goddess Empress of Earth:
image
We can hear her (voiced by Aya Hirano). Feel her (though if I were to do so, she'd smack me and shout 'Chigau! Sekuhara? Ecchi sukebe!'). And see her (the anime, light novels, manga, figurines etc).
And Haruhi Suzumiya is God after all. So I guess she has one up on your Judeo-Christian God.