Maximum Feels said:

The best females would be thoseapproaching their first pregnancy so that they would have all their breeding years ahead of them and the time you'd have to wait before they'd start reproducing would be at a minimum.

Taking 17 as the typical age of first conception this would generally mean girls in the 12-16 bracket, right?

Buger Sauce:
Now, that's a simple powerful piece of reasoning and here's some data that support your prediction. Several thousand men on the internet were shown pictures of girls and women of all ages and, without being informed of their age, asked if they found them sexually desirable. The graph below shows the result. The peak is between 13 and 16. I suspect that the sharp drop under 13 is partly caused by many men guessing the girls were under 13 and being reluctant to rate them as attractive. The true rating for girls that young is probably a bit higher than that reported but still your prediction that men should have evolved find girls around 14 the most desirable appears to be smack on. Excellent thinking.

image