even the theory of gravity is wrong: it works in some cases, but not in others. For example, if I drop a book, then I can tell you how it falls towards the ground, but if I pick something very large or very small our theory of gravity stops working.
14 comments
Wow. Now how to market this "Antigravity" device to NASA to help launch payloads into orbit...
"Okay t-minus six...begin primary cluster dumbass lift...sequence initiated...GodGuy 1 has liftoff...this is the first launch of a human powered spacecraft, and unfortunately they only lifted it above their heads..."
I think he's talking about 'very small' as in electrons, quarks, etc. and 'very large' as in stars and stuff. I think he's trying to get at the idea that Newtonian gravity is only an approximation, especially noticeable in the macro- and microscopes.
While _his_ 'theory of gravity' might not 'work' there is no evidence of any cases where the one accepted by the rest of us (general relativity) makes false predictions. The accuracy of its predictions have allowed us to make things that have improved our lives (eg GPS, which depends on predictions about gravity so accurate that Newton's theory isn't up to the job). It is a good theory.
I am not saying it is a perfect theory. There is currently no direct evidence for extra dimensions (although experiments to test for them will be conducted using particle accelerators in the near future) and it is impossible to formulate a renormalisable quantum theory of gravity in the number of dimensions we observe so it is clearly not the last word on the subject.
“even the theory of gravity is wrong:”
There are people in my building that measure it daily. But go on…?
“it works in some cases, but not in others.”
I imagine you’re expectations vary more than gravity does.
“For example, if I drop a book, then I can tell you how it falls towards the ground,”
Ah. with the pages flapping from air resistance and shit.
“but if I pick something very large or very small our theory of gravity stops working.”
Um… No. You are incorrect, sir.The air still resists the bowling ball’s descent, but there’s just no visible flapping bits. And if you drop a Kleenex, there’s a lot MORE air resistance to the paper in relation to the mass of the tissue.
Try it in a vacuum where you measure JUST the gravity.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.