Kara Dansky #transphobia

Kara Dansky #transphobia karadansky.com

ACKNOWLEDGING “TRANS” AS A COHERENT CONCEPT IS A FATAL OWN GOAL FOR FEMINISTS

Can everyone please stop saying “trans people?”

1. It makes no sense.

2. It’s a lie, and fighting self-ID is not enough to defeat it.

3. The entire edifice of “trans” is built on a capitalist enterprise to obliterate the material reality of sex, deprive all of us of our natural human experience, and center male sexual entitlement.

It may at first appear inconsistent to say that “trans” is all three things. But it’s true: “trans” is simultaneously incoherent, an outright lie, and an industry that viciously fights to destroy reality and sell a fetish.

For all three of these reasons, I want to make the case that use of terms like “trans,” “trans gender,” and “trans people” by feminists and other gender critical people is an own goal – a goal scored inadvertently when the ball is struck into the goal by a player on the defensive team. Use of this terminology is likely to destroy the movement to fight gender ideology.

[...]

“Trans people” as a concept makes no sense

Sex means the differentiation between male and female, determined by whether an X-bearing sperm or a Y-bearing sperm fertilized the X-bearing ovum, which determines the type of sexual and reproductive organs that develop, and the biological differences between females and males.

There is also, of course, the phenomenon of “intersex,” or “sex-linked disorders,” which are defined as “any disease or abnormal condition that is determined by the sex chromosomes or by a defective gene on a sex chromosome.”[1] The phenomenon of intersex is unrelated to the fight against gender ideology.[2]

None of this, however, tells us anything about what the word “trans” or “trans people” might mean. People are all always male or female – men or women, girls or boys – and sex is fixed in each human body. Ceding that “trans,” by any definition, even a definition that equates it with nonconformity with sex role stereotypes, is a thing at all, fatally denies the reality of sex. This is because sex and “transgender” ideology cannot be logically reconciled. Either trans exists or sex exists.

[...]

9 comments

“ACKNOWLEDGING “TRANS” AS A COHERENT CONCEPT IS A FATAL OWN GOAL FOR FEMINISTS”
So, having no actual arguments against it, you just deny that it exists. That always works.

"[trans people] makes no sense.”
You sound just like the Xians who denied SameSex marriage as a concept. I suspect you echo men who said ’women’s sufferage’ made no sense.

"[trans people] is a lie, and fighting self-ID is not enough to defeat it.”
The concept is older than you are, as are some of the treatments. You’re not going to ‘defeat’ it any more than you can ‘defeat’ abortion. Just drive it underground.

"For all three of these reasons, I want to make the case that use of terms like “trans,” “trans gender,” and “trans people” by feminists and other gender critical people is an own goal"
You’re misusing ‘feminist’ to mean ‘born-woman-gatekeeper.’ Or, you know, ‘bigot.’

“Use of this terminology is likely to destroy the movement to fight gender ideology.”
Yes, DEALING with actual issue is problematic, it would reduce your ability to claim it’s a fetish, or a misogynist attack.

“Sex means the differentiation between male and female,”
To a biologist, ‘sex’ means the exchange of genetic material. So, one-celled bacteria can have sex, but a married man with a vasectomy isn’t having sex with his wife.
You need to be very careful to attribute your definitions and provide context.
But then, if you want to be taken seriously, you need to use the actual words. And that’s a losing argument for you.

You need to read more about these chromosomes and gender identity. Sex isn't exclusively linked to the X or Y and it seems to be a range on various things rather than a cut and dry this is male, this is female.

Sec and gender aren't the same thing either.

As a English word, it makes perfect sense.

There is also, of course, the phenomenon of “intersex,” or “sex-linked disorders,”

Intersex is NOT the same thing as sex-linked disorders. According to the Cleveland Clinic,

People who are intersex have genitals, chromosomes or reproductive organs that don’t fit into a male/female sex binary. Their genitals might not match their reproductive organs, or they may have traits of both. Being intersex may be evident at birth, childhood, later in adulthood or never. Being intersex isn’t a disorder, disease or condition.

https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/16324-intersex

Sex means the differentiation between male and female, determined by whether an X-bearing sperm or a Y-bearing sperm fertilized the X-bearing ovum, which determines the type of sexual and reproductive organs that develop, and the biological differences between females and males.

Sex chromosomes were discovered only in the beginning of the Twentieth Century!

There is also, of course, the phenomenon of “intersex,” or “sex-linked disorders,”

…wow…
You truly fail genetics of sex forever.

“Can everyone please stop saying “trans people?””

No. We will not. Die mad.

Trans People.

What the fuck are you going to do about it…?!

Sex means the differentiation between male and female, determined by whether an X-bearing sperm or a Y-bearing sperm fertilized the X-bearing ovum, which determines the type of sexual and reproductive organs that develop, and the biological differences between females and males.

And gender means whether the person perceive themselves as male or female, if either. In most people, their gender and sex overlap; but in some they don’t.

Greetings, from The illuminati world elite empire, i am here to bring the good news to the world, and to tell the world how good illuminati can help you achieve your dreams. Bringing the poor, the needy and the talented to the limelight of fame, riches, powers and security, get recognized in your business, political race, rise to the top in whatever you do, be protected spiritually and physically! All these you will achieve in a twinkle of an eye when you get initiated into the great Illuminati brotherhood empire, once you are initiated to the great Illuminati empire, you will have numerous benefits, join the Illuminati brotherhood today and get an instant rich, this intention is to build up your financial status as a new member of the Illuminati elite, this is one out of the numerous benefits that are given to our newly recruited members who join the Illuminati brotherhood, we also want to let you know this, if you have been scammed before you have nothing to worry about, because we are going to fix that, and you will get all that you have lost, we have helped so many people in different countries who have been scammed thousands of dollars, so you have nothing to worry about, because we are here and ready to help you, you are in the right place where you can join the illuminati without having any kinds of problems or difficulties. Note that this message was created solely for the purpose of our recruitment scheme which will ends by december and this offer is meant for unique ones only, if you are not serious on joining the Illuminati empire secret society, you are advised not to contact us at all. This is because disloyalty is highly not tolerated here in our organisation, do you agree to be a member of The Great Illuminati new world order? If you do, kindly reply back through this direct recruitment email only at: initiationchurchofdevil@gmail.com or WhatsApp +1(502)297-1152 for more information on how to join, and for more instructions on our membership process.Hail The Great Illuminati brotherhood...