I went and looked at the letter. It’s similar to other letters that my colleagues and I would receive every so often when I was an advisor at a big state research university.
From the letter:
I’ll be visiting my student this weekend. It’s helpful that colleges have Family Weekend programs as it “legitimizes” parents coming to visit and being out and about on campus. Thanks for any role you have in preparing this opportunity.
Most universities do some sort of parents or family weekend, usually scheduled in the beginning of the fall semester and aimed at the families of incoming freshman. It’s intended as a way for parents to get to know the school a little, and to meet their students’ teachers and see what and where the students are learning.
While parents’/family weekends can “legitimize” parents on campus, most university staff are able to spot and trained (at least somewhat) to deal with helicopter parents.
For instance, while parents can always access their child’s information in a K-12 situation, they can only access very limited information regarding a university student. Since most university students are over 18, they have the right to privacy, including from their parents. And even for that level of information (majors, minors, address, phone number, advisor name, club affiliations, etc) a parent’s access depends on whether or not the student with allow it. If a student’s record is marked ‘P’ in the system, staff can’t give out any information at all. Some universities use different markings and abbreviations but it all comes down to the same thing. This was originally designed around abusive parents who have been ordered to stay away from their children, but it also has turned out to be an important protection when it comes to spouses or really anyone else trying to get information that doesn’t belong to them. Sometimes we couldn’t even confirm whether a student is enrolled at all. When we could give information out, we just had to say “I can’t give out that information”.
I’m guessing this student will be marking their records as private.
In addition to being a parent, I’m also a lifelong feminist, Democrat, and champion of higher education. As a result, I know the importance of science and credible research, that people can’t change sex, that children are not born into the “wrong body,” that misogyny is real, and that women and girls’ long-fought and hard-won sex-based rights matter.
Sigh… you know what’s also real? Transmisogyny. And trans women and men getting rights and protections actually makes protections for all women stronger. I know this in part because my state just voted in one of those awful laws that makes it so students can only join teams that match their gender assigned at birth. And since the measure itself never stated which ways that the school could confirm a student’s gender, it’s been left up to the schools themselves. And now girls are facing potential examinations just so they can play sports.
I’ve done a deep dive into gender ideology because it has captured my child. I believe my child got caught up in this to find an “easy” answer to navigating puberty and adolescence and this, paired with neurodivergence, the pandemic lockdown, and access to the internet, all collided to cause mental health distress and adoption of an over-valued belief that identifying as the opposite sex was “the answer.” And to my heartbreak and their health detriment they accessed a puberty blocking drug used to sterilize animals and harmful synthetic cross-sex hormones online.
TBH, if I had gotten a letter like this I would likely have taken it to my boss and confirmed what the most reasonable response. That is, if I hadn’t already tossed it in the trash. A parent is allowed to behave like this when their student is in K-12 or primary school or whatever, but they can’t at a university level. At that level the student is expected to be able to speak for themselves. So, anything like ‘I believe my students is trans because bla bla bla’ would be met with either silence or ‘I can’t discuss your student’s medical/psychological issues, if you need information about this you’ve got to speak to your student.’
I anticipate that you are a provider on a college campus because you care about helping students. I suspect that you are frequently immensely helpful to students who are struggling with mental distress anywhere on the continuum – from initial homesickness to severe psychological disorders.
I’m genuinely concerned that the college is adhering to WPATH guidelines, as advertised on the website, in their work with students identifying as trans. WPATH is a corrupt organization and researchers, journalists, and attorneys have exposed the guidelines as a very harmful sham.
Ugh… the university staff et al are going to have a nightmare with this one. “You’re probably a great psychologist and maybe you even like the students!! But here’s how I know more than you and everyone else in the world. I’ve done as much *research as faculty at your school.”
I hope you will review these resources and learn more about WPATH in support of your work with students struggling from mental distress presenting as gender dysphoria or body dysmorphia.
And after that followed a bunch of articles that I might link later, I’ve got to go to bed!!
*if by ‘research’ they mean Google searches and looking at random websites that say what you want to hear!