The Books: Inappropriate Content for Young Minds

The books at the center of Mahmoud v. Taylor were part of Montgomery County’s “Inclusive Storybook” collection, intended to promote diversity but often introducing complex, adult-oriented themes to very young children. Here are some of the specific titles highlighted in the case:

Uncle Bobby’s Wedding by Sarah S. Brannen (kindergarten): This book follows a young guinea pig whose uncle marries his male partner, presenting same-sex marriage as a normalized family event. For five-year-olds, this introduces concepts of romantic relationships that may be confusing or irrelevant to their developmental stage.

IntersectionAllies: We Make Room for All by Chelsea Johnson, LaToya Council, and Carolyn Choi (1st grade): This book explores intersecting identities, including gender identity, race, and disability, with a focus on allyship. Its discussion of gender fluidity and complex social concepts risks overwhelming young children who lack the context to process such ideas.

Pride Puppy! by Robin Stevenson (pre-K or early elementary): This story depicts a family attending a Pride parade, introducing kink and BDSM. For children as young as 3–5.

Born Ready: The True Story of a Boy Named Penelope by Jodie Patterson (elementary grades): This book tells the story of a transgender child who identifies as a boy, focusing on gender transitioning and self-identification. For elementary students, this narrative promotes a specific perspective on gender that may conflict with many families’ values and beliefs, especially when taught without parental consent or opt-out options.