Also can we talk about the part where he seems to imply that the US was at one point 100 percent Christian? Because it was not. Never has been. In 1776, there were probably about 2,000 Jews in the US, 0.1% of the population. Enough, at any rate, for George Washington to write to Touro synagogue that the US gives “to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance” – a blatant lie, but oh well.
Those Jews were, like most Americans, mixed in their sympathies. But Jews were and are instrumental to America, as have people of other or no religions (Thomas Paine was scandalously not Christian, for instance).
Susan B Anthony, W.E.B DuBois, H. L. Mencken, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Mark Twain, and Robert Ingersoll (no longer famous today, but quite controversial in his time as an outspoken agnostic) were agnostic. Isaac Asimov and Orson Welles were atheist.
Franklin, Washington, Paine, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe—all deists, along with Lincoln, Neil Armstrong, and others.
Samuel Gompers (founder of the AFL, now part of the AFL-CIO, a huge labor union), Stan Lee, the creators of Superman, Will Eisner, Jack Kirby, Irving Berlin, Louis Brandeis, Felix Frankfurter (a real Supreme Court justice!), RBG, the inventor of jeans (they’re Levi’s, not Smith’s), the Marx Brothers, Uriah Levy (who did…a lot in his time), Judah Touro (one of the largest philanthropists of his time), Francis Salvador (“Paul Revere of the South”), Haym Salomon (provided invaluable financial help–well, actually quite valuable, but you know–in the Revolutionary war), Mordecai Sheftall (Revolutionary War colonel), Henry Morgenthau (basically designed the New Deal), Fiorello La Guardia (on his mom’s side, to be fair), Albert Einstein, Judy Blume, Emma Lazarus, Bob Dylan, and Joseph Pulitzer, among so many others, were Jewish.
And Muslims? Hell, they were in what would become the US before Protestantism existed! (https://aeon.co/essays/muslims-lived-in-america-before-protestantism-even-existed).
There is no idyllic past where everyone could be united by the Christian Bible, by the Lord’s Prayer, by anything else Christian, not in America.
America isn’t a Christian nation, and it never has been, and that’s wonderful, and non-Christians have given so much more to America than Ben Pollock and his ilk ever could.