‘Gender’ is not a fact, anymore, but a feeling. Male ‘gender’ is now a feeling that belongs to females who cut their breasts off and take testosterone. It does not belong to every boy, because some boys will want to be girls. Fatherhood is no longer connected to biology. Fatherhood is now ‘found family’, such as Bella Ramsey declaring “I’m gonna be a dad” to her pregnant girlfriend on The Last of Us.
7 comments
“‘Gender’ is not a fact, anymore, but a feeling.”
I think the entire point is that it’s always been a feeling. And for about a hundred years we’ve known the 30 or so human traits that create that feeling. USUALLY they agree with the genitals, but not always.
“Male ‘gender’ is now a feeling that belongs to females who cut their breasts off and take testosterone.”
Again, for almost 100 years, science has found that the best treatment for dysphoria is transition. If this boggles your mind, that’s your problem.
“It does not belong to every boy, because some boys will want to be girls.”
No. Some people that YOU would call boys (“PENIS!PENIS!PENIS!”) are actually girls. do try to keep up.
“Fatherhood is no longer connected to biology.”
Fatherhood has never been LIMITED to biology. My coworker has two girls he loves but shares no genetics with. They have half-siblings they email, products of the same donor at the sperm bank.
“Fatherhood is now ‘found family’,"
it’s all or nothing with you, isn’t it? The condition is expanded, not replaced, but all you see is that everything you knew is wrong?
Geeze what a snowflake
LGBTQ+ people exist. Including those who are non-binary and genderfluid.
Reality doesn’t care about your ‘feelings’, OP.
That’s a little bit off, but even if it were all precisely true… what would be the problem with that, exactly?
Fatherhood is now ‘found family’
Wait, I think I see the problem. They’re being told that their “superior” traditional lifestyles (or at least ideals, if they don’t yet live that way) are now on the same level as “inferior” alternative ones. For most people this doesn’t mean much because they never felt that their lifestyle was “superior” if they lived a more traditional way even if they’ve been repeatedly told that, so alternatives being “uplifted” doesn’t degrade their own marriage/family/relationships in any way. But for tradcons, everything about them including their lifestyle being “superior” is part of their identity, so being equal to an “inferior” person in any respect feels degrading.
<@KeithInc. > #259278
Conservatives are emotionally dependent on the concept of boundaries . Boundaries keep us all separate, neat and tidy in our own little boxes, never touching for fear of getting cooties from the "wrong" or "icky" people.
Anything that crosses boundaries -- or worse, declares that boundaries do not matter -- is so disgusting and obscene that conservatives immediately reject it with all their strength. It's a knee-jerk reaction, like gagging at the smell of garbage.
And they're furious that the rest of us don't share their revulsion.
@Zinnia #259285
Couldn't have said it better myself.
‘Gender’ is not a fact, anymore, but a feeling.
That’s kinda….right for the wrong reasons. In that gender isn’t a biological fact, it’s about who you identify as. That whole post is kinda “accidental ally” material, really.
And sorry, Matt, despite having a very similar name, you’ll never be as cool as Matt Osborne (RIP), the pro wrestler known as “Maniac” Matt Borne, and the original (and by far the best) “Doink the Clown”.
@Zinnia #259285
The problem people like Matt have with it is if there aren’t clear boundaries between the genders, then there isn’t a clear hierarchy and if someone with a penis can be a woman and vice versa, then men aren’t actually better than women. And his entire worldview depends on him being ‘better’ than women, POC, LGBTQIAA2S+ people, etc.
I just noticed your other response. It’s not just their lifestyles, it’s them themselves. All his life he’s thought that men are superior to women, that whites are superior to POC, that straights are superior to LGBTQIAA2S+ people, that able are superior to PWD, that neurotypicals are superior to neurodivergents, etc. Stuff like this blows his entire (and entirely wrong) hierarchy to bits.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.