Stalin tried to increase farm output in Ukraine. The famine was caused by the farmers burning their crops in protest.
16 comments
Here in Kumgang land, the famine was caused by farmers burning their crops down! Also, Bernie Sanders won the popular vote in 2016, the most-worshipped god in America is Queztacoatl, and polar bears are black.
Yes, Stalin tried to improve crop yields, by insisting every farmer across the entire Soviet Union do things he once heard some farmer was doing. Not sure if he even heard if the farmer was successful, but now basically every farmer in the entire USSR had to do the same things, no matter where they were, what climate they had, or even what crops they were growing. If the Ukrainians actually did burn the crops in protest, it’s because they knew they were going to fail to meet quotas anyway, because they were required to do crap that wouldn’t work for their crops in their climate, and Stalin’s Politburo would fucking listen.
More likely the famine was caused by requiring the same techniques for all crops, all climates, all soils, even all specific events throughout the growing season, and several farmers ending up falling short because they followed the Kremlin’s orders rather than doing what they knew was best for their farm, because for the farmers entire nations going hungry better than they themselves getting shot.
@Lizard_People_Operative #43269
Here in Kumgang land, the famine was caused by farmers burning their crops down! Also, Bernie Sanders won the popular vote in 2016, the most-worshipped god in America is Queztacoatl, and polar bears are black.
And also, brown means stop and pink means go, there’s a Revenge Of The Nerds remake where the nerds and the jocks are forced to join up against terrorists, the most popular fast food is elephant meat burgers and George Floyd survived.
Stalin tried increasing farm output, by applying the ideas of Lysenko.
Lysenko was a crackpot who came up with a bizzare model that combined Lamarckian evolution with some silly notions of patriotism being the best fertilizer.
When Lysenko’s experiment failed, he blamed the farmers. He especially blamed the Kulak farmers. Accusing them of disloyalty, and of plotting a revolt against Stalin. Stalin, and more importantly Beria, believed Lysenko.
When real biologists protested that Lysenko’s methods were nonsense, and completely unsupported by evidence, Lysenko told Beria that the biologists were conspiring with Britain.
When crops failed, Lysenko accused farmers of burning them.
When horticulturists and botanists held up the fact that Darwinian selection refuted Lamarckian adaptation, Lysenko denounced Darwin as “A petty bourgeois reactionary”.
Stalin and Beria put their full might behind Lysenko, and punished anyone who dared challenge him.
The result was a disaster, made worse by the blind belief that Lysenko was right.
@DLaurier #43278
This in turn had the consequence that while Russia pretty much kept up with the US when it came to physics during the whole Cold War, they were severely lacking behind in genetics and biology in general. Might even be one of the many factors for its ultimate collapse. Lysenko was one of the biggest scam artists (or alternatively delusional, narcissistic idiot) of the 20th century. So pretty much perfect company for asshole extraordinaire Stalin. Blaming the farmers for the resulting crop failures is just low and stupid, but I expect nothing else from Tankies.
Yes, farmers burned their own crops because they were so stupid and wanted to be mean and protest poor nice innocent Mr. Stalin. Yeah, that’s definitely what happened. He never sent in people to steal grain so people starved, never.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.