@Vgal #215768
Firstly, I’m so sorry about the bird’s nest situation. That must have been utterly awful.
Secondly, with the teachers’ response to bullying you mentioned, that was my experience, too. A very few cared, most didn’t. I fought back a few times and got treated as if I was being just as bad. And I sort-of get it if they don’t know what actually happened beyond a few vague details, but it’s still spirit-crushing.
In middle school, when I was at my wit’s end because there were 30 of us in my class and everyone seemed to have a go at various times. If most of them were interested in something else, someone was likely to be interested in annoying Hayley. It was a past-time. So when I reached a point where I knew nobody was going to help, I started lashing out. I did that 2 or 3 times before our teacher told me to stay back after class and told me, “I’m becoming… concerned, about how you’re attacking your classmates.” I don’t remember how I responded, I don’t think I’d have tried to explain because the lack of curiosity or empathy was so palpable. Like you said, she wanted a peaceful life, not to try and figure out what the right thing to do might be. I stopped lashing out so that she didn’t escalate to getting the headmaster involved, or something. Or worse, she might have told my mum, and if that happened, I’d get extra hell at home. There was already enough of that.
Another time, in middle school, a girl who… I suspect might not have done that much, she was just the most recent in a long line of people testing my patience, was being annoying, so I grabbed her and thumped my fist right in the middle of her back. It hurt her, and she left groaning. I don’t remember if I ever heard about that again, though I’ve got a vague feeling I might have gotten in trouble for that.
Then, once, in secondary school, one or two of my classmates were doing something with a ruler - hitting or poking me with it, maybe? I really don’t remember. So I snatched it from them and put it in my bag. They immediately shouted for the teacher, who came over, looking like she was going to put a stop to this *right now*. She asked to see the ruler, and I thought maybe she wanted to see proof that a ruler had been involved? Obviously not in hindsight, but that’s the sense it made to me. As soon as I showed it to her she snatched it out of my hand and gave it back to the bullies.
But going back to the question of what grown-ups are supposed to do, I think it’s hopeless of the grown ups to figure out what really went on between the kids involved. Some things I was thinking of though, was this:
- Educate yourself about psychological concepts like stamp collecting, the Drama Triangle, the Poison Parrot, racket feelings, and the beach ball experiment. All of these highlight dynamics that might be going on.
- Forget about trying to work out who did what, and who the real victim is. Both your story and mine both highlight that kids will misattribute events, and I can attest that the moment you strike back, you “hit them for no reason,” which can and will be corroborated by their friends. With that said, if one child seems unhappy most of the time, even when they don’t think they’re being watched, and perhaps spends a lot of time alone, that might be your clue about who the victim is.
- Consider reaching out to the parents of the main kids involved. If, and how, to reach out might vary depending on the situation, but the primary question needs to be what the landscape at home is like, without even raising the issue of the child’s bullying to start with. Is it possible there’s something going on at home where the bully child feels powerless, frustrated, scared? This could easily get into social worker territory, so I want to make clear I’m saying here that this is something to do in a spirit of being neighbourly. It’s a context-gathering mission. Is the family at home struggling? Are they isolated? If they’re better supported and integrated, then the bullying may simmer down of its own accord. May do, may not - but I suspect this would be a solid start. Literally make it a matter of sidling up to them at school drop-off, pick-up, or school gatherings and say, “Hi, I’m from 6 doors down from you. How are you doing?” Leave talk of the kids out of it, at least for now.
- If appropriate given your relationship to the children involved, teach them the above mentioned psychological concepts. Some of them throw new insight into what’s going on at school. They might help the kids to shift what’s going on, they might not, but knowledge is power.
- Treat all the children involved with respect. They don’t have much freedom, and their thoughts are often not given much credence. It’s such a breath of fresh air for kids to be treated with respect that it may help the situation.
- Ultimately, the children need to do some of the work to straighten this out between themselves, so know you can’t be a saviour, only a support.
I’m still testing this stuff out and would be interested to hear your thoughts, if you’re up for sharing them? Same goes for anyone else reading this.