@Vgal #214962
Though it’s also part of my imposter syndrome in regards to womanhood. Sometimes, I just can’t help but think: Given that I basically went through the vast majority of my life as a man, and I never went through these negative formative experiences that are pretty much universal for (cis) women… then what right do I have to call myself a woman?
Managing your own imposter syndrome is a challenge and a process in itself, but anyone who tries to make you feel like an imposter isn’t worth your time. We’re all on our own journeys, and yours is simply different from mine. As a woman who was raised as a boy and lived as a man, you’re privy to a binocular view of life that I don’t have. I think that’s awesome and I’m always keen to hear what you have to say. Well, unless I’m going through a hermit phrase, but that’s a me thing, not a you thing.
Negative formative experiences do tend to make each of us into something other than we’d have become without it. That much is true. But you? Without having had those, you’ll be unfettered in ways that many of us yearn for. I’m comfortable admitting to that yearning; some people are not, and I think that contributes towards why some people act shitty towards trans folk. That’s their stuff to process, and it’s not their business to make it yours.
For what it’s worth, I hear a similar story from my male clients again and again: the extreme unpleasantness of locker room culture. Gentle-spirited boys, solitary boys, thoughtful and intelligent boys who see the dynamic and have no time for it, were nonetheless subjected to that rule: either you’re loud, brash, aggressive, treat others with contempt, and are physically big, or you’re fodder to be dominated.
I wasn’t even raised with that, and I want less of it in my life. I can’t imagine what it’s like having that in your history. I’m even loosely looking into whether I can support the foundation of a support or therapy group for the men who never liked the locker room dynamic: so many men avoid going to mens’ mental health groups because they expect that dynamic, and it’s getting in the way of mens’ mental health. But imagine if such a group existed! Those men would be smashing the patriarchy and I’m absolutely here for that thought!
But to my knowledge, nobody has ever considered me desirable either. And they probably never will. At this point, I’m largely resigned to spending the rest of my life single. Even though I don’t really want to.
I’m so sorry. That sounds painful. At the risk of offering advice when you didn’t ask for it, keep on with the journey you’re on. You may find that as you’re more able to present authentically, people are attracted to that energy.
That said, I suppose being invisible and lonely is at least better than being harassed or worse, so I shouldn’t complain.
No no - complain. This is your experience. I like being ignored sexually because I have actually experienced being seen as attractive at times I haven’t wanted it, and been sexually harassed too, so that factors in. With that said, some of that attention was when I was too young to get it, so that may be why I’m so disinterested in being seen as attractive. As a mid-to-older teenager my mum got very invested in me dating, and set me up with a colleague who must have been in his mid 20s, some guy who called our house to buy a computer or car or something and who offered to take me out for a drink when I answered the phone, and a biker guy who lived around the corner. I don’t like the connotations of what she wanted to happen, there. I was also questioned at a road crossing by a man who wanted to have a conversation about what was written on my tshirt when I was about 14, which felt weird at the time, was grabbed at a kids’ club when there was nobody else in the room (I was 8, I think?), and my own brother laughed and made lewd comments when I was 4 and ate a carrot as a snack. Because apparently, a little girl putting a vaguely phallic shaped piece of food in her mouth makes that okay.
I should say here, I’m so glad you’ve not had these sorts of experiences. I think that if you haven’t, then being seen as attractive is a much better prospect. So, go and enjoy it! I can’t, really, but I wouldn’t begrudge somebody else enjoying attractiveness for a second.
I sometimes think that even if through some miracle someone eventually does end up wanting to be with me, my first question to them upon finding it out might be “Why?? Just… why me of all people?” And the best thing I could say to them if I actually had the strength to do so would be “Trust me, you can find someone better.” Especially if it’s someone I would also be into.
This has echoes of what you said earlier. I don’t want to offer suggestions this time, I just want to say that I’m sorry you’ve got this barrier in the way. But I experience you as sincere and authentic, and I have huge respect for you.
To wrap this up: you and I each have very different sets of life experiences, and I’m so glad we can communicate across that gap and talk about these things. Stay authentic, friend!