( ValkyrieAtTheDisco )
The idea that there are 'happy trans' people strikes me to be as much of a myth as the 'happy hooker' myth. Sure, there are people who have yet to experience the worst harms of it, and people who have convinced themselves that they're fine in order to not face the reality of it, but the foundations of either situation and the beliefs that lead them to be possible are harmful. Misogyny is at the heart of both.
SWERF’N’TERF, eh?
Also, to maintain your worldview of moralistic prescriptivism, you must profess that the objects of your theorizing are ALL just deluded and lying to themselves!
Now that’s what we call an extraordinary claim!
Sure, lady, everyone except you and your ilk is wrong, ESPECIALLY people who — unlike you! — have actual lived experience being transgender or/and sex workers. Suuuure.
Your entire house of cards of a worldview rests on conspiracism and everyone who opposes or criticizes you being liars or delusional. Only you are right; only you can ever be right.
And then your kind has the temerity to claim being rational, logical, sane and a bulwark against brainwashing.
( TheKnitta )
The reality is that you cannot change sex. How anyone can claim to be genuinely happy while living a lie is beyond me.
Maybe because it’s not a lie at all. The lie would be if I still pretended I’m a man.
And the reality is that you can change sex, to a point. Parts of it. Not all, but enough.
Besides, I don’t claim to have XX chromosomes. Or to produce large gametes.
But then again, I don’t need to.
Every moment of the day, you’d have to check yourself to remind yourself to play act.
Oh, not at all. For instance, I kind of surprised myself with how easily and naturally female pronouns and gendered language came to me, when I refer to myself. From the start.
Or perhaps it shouldn’t be a surprise at all. I merely freed myself enough to tell the truth about me. To be who I am.
And that, my dear Ovarite, is no effort at all. Not when you’re free to be yourself.
Every look, every ‘mis’gendering would rankle so much.
No. There is a slight pain when I’m being deliberately misgendered, but I’m used to it by the person who insistently does it.
The others? It’s just an old habit that hasn’t been entirely replaced by a new habit yet. So, no ‘rankling’.
You’d be full of ire at the members of the sex you were emulating. Why do it to yourself?
Huh? No, why would I be full of ire at cis women??
What even is the logic here?
I have enough experience having waded through so much of the muck of TERF ideology that I can usually understand their weasel words and their actual meanings when they’re obscured by uncommon use of language or misframing of concepts and things.
But even I’m having difficulty parsing this one.
The only thing I can come up with is the canard that we’re very envious at cis women because they have what trans women don’t and/or have it ‘naturally’. But I’m not sure that’s even it, here.
(makeitmakesense )
It is sad tho as I have a couple of trans Identified family members, and there really is no place for them in this new emerging gender critical world view. I think lots of people are going to think like the author of this post in years to come. [...]
Sad?! Oh, spare me the fake crocodile tears.
You outright admit there’s no place for us in your “new emerging gender critical world view”… and yet you work towards bringing about this hostile new reality.
Yet another example of how gender-critical views eliminate empathy.