"… unless you want to write off all value, preference, feeling and meaning as “illusion,” which amounts to gaslighting.”
Nope. Saying ‘we can explain emotions without woo’ AND THEN SHOWING THE EXPERIMENTS THAT SUPPORT THIS,’ is the opposite of gaslighting.
You attribute such to a soul, without ever producing evidence that souls exist. You just ‘know in your heart’ that it’s true.
“What if the reverse is true? The only real thing is actually irrationality, and all the rational materialism is simply a catalyst for experiencing things?”
Okay, what if?
But more importantly, what can you POSSIBLY do to convince me that this is, in fact, the case?
Stick a probe in someone’s brain, show that stimulation in THIS spot creates feelings of love, THEREFORE in my ehart of hearts, i know the brain is NOT the source of emotions. It’s incoherent, which is your premise, but how do you know it’s the RIGTH incoherent rather than some other illogic?
“The answer to this great question has massive implications, not just in this realm, btw.”
Not until you can explain how we’d ever be able to answer that question, if it’s right.
"For example, crime and punishment. Why are we torturing prisoners in prison who were just following their programming?”
Whether it’s programming or choice, they’re still a threat to society, i think society has a right to isolate them to prevent further harm. Not to torture, but still, to imprison.