( MarthaMMC )
Advocates say the conservative push to define “sex” is not only politically motivated but goes against basic biology.
How has science & medicine been so corrupted as to lie like this?
It hasn’t.
And their claims that this erases tran people- it just sets boundaries.
…by erasing us as a category, a social reality, and by actually erasing any rights that are specific to us and which we need for protection and living our lives as who we are. You know, the same exact thing you accuse us of doing to (cis) women.
They also lie about kids, saying that they don't get surgery.
I’ll halfway give you that. Yes, in some places and under extraordinary circumstances, top surgery for minors does happen.
But it’s not that people *lie* about this not happening. As someone who knows people who have made such claims (including on this very site), I can confidently say they made the claim due to ignorance, not malice or deception.
In other words, they just really thought such surgeries don’t happen at all.
They also claim that there are no incidents or proof that TIPs are a danger to women & girls when they use single sex facilities. When the rapes that occur in prisons in other countries & in the US disprove that.
Sure there are.
Yep. I, a trans woman, am telling you: there are incidents, and there is indeed a danger.
There’s a danger every time people congregate in the same place. Any people. Sometimes, there will be abusers among them.
But the question isn’t whether there is a danger; that there is one, goes without saying. The questions we should be asking instead are:
- How large is the danger? Does our presence significantly increase the rate of abuse? Do we have accurate data about it that, when contextualized, shows that we are a clear and present major danger?
- What, if anything, should we do about the danger, specifically?
- How do we accurately assess the danger without falling into baseless fearmongering? (important in the current climate!)
- If we’re going to curtail trans people’s access to certain spaces, how do we weigh the competing needs of cis women and trans people (especially trans women)? Because let’s not pretend that this wouldn’t negatively affect us.
But you don’t want a honest, respectful discussion or a compromise. You want total victory, and an unquestionable segregation of ourselves from cis women.
As well as TIMs own social media posts about flashing & leaving semen in women's restrooms.
Look, lady, your adventures when it comes to shock-viewing trans women’s OnlyFans-related accounts are your own thing, but please don’t involve me in that — especially by alleging that this accurately reflects what I or other trans women do. Also, remember: Porn is not an accurate reflection of real life.
As well as exposing male genitalia to women & girls in changing rooms. […] There needs to be a list of such incidents to use as factual evidence.
Yes, because when our people (allegedly) do it, it’s somehow representative of ALL of us, the whole demographic… while when cis folk do it, it’s just “isolated incidents”. Me and mine are supposed to answer for and take the fall for EVERY trans person who does a bad thing, while you only get to answer and face consequences for what you, MarthaMMC, have personally done.
After all, it would be so unfair and wrong to limit your rights and your access to places for things some strangers from your particular demographics have done, right?
Yet it’s only “common sense” and a “protective necessity” to do it to us. And if we object to this, we are obviously “advocating rape and the erosion of women’s rights”. Can’t be anything else, no ma’am.
How wonderful.
It also claims that trans ppl are in danger of being outed if their documents don't match their gender identity.
We obviously are.
TBH, most are outed by their appearance-esp TIMs.
I don’t know about ‘most’ (see: Toupee fallacy), but regardless, it is something that we need, and not just those of us who currently ‘pass’.
For many trans people, the sex marker change is an important element of recognition for them, even if they’re visibly trans. It means a lot to them to be officially recognized as who they are.