I’ll sum up my argument with this awesome song text from Hazbin Hotel:
If Hell is forever, then Heaven must be a lie
If angels can do whatever and remain in the sky
The rules are shades of grey, when you don't do as you say
When you make the wretched suffer just to kill them again!
Sung by a Seraphim and Lucifer’s daughter in duet.
In more detail, if you ask me, infinite punishment for a finite crime is simply not just and outright evil. Especially if you’ve already come to terms with your sins and guilt.
No, a PROPER Hell would be a place where “sinners” would be rehabilitated. Not tortured out of sheer sadism, but rather confronted with their own, respective sins so they could accept what they did wrong, and genuinely try to better themselves. And then, once you’ve fully improved as a person, you can go to your own, hard-earned paradise.
Strange that in at least two settings (Lucifer and Hazbin Hotel) is the friggin’ Devils who get this epiphany first. “Hell doesn’t need a warden, it needs a healer.”
So fuck you and fuck your pointlessly sadistic god.