C. Denial - They are so uncomfortable with the implications, they will deny it no matter how strong the evidence.
That's like for gods of the gaps and afterall, ETs are often the new demons of old adapted with pseudoscience. Because there's no evidence and that when there's actually something it's discovered to be a balloon or human airplane or other mundane explanation, they must have superpowers, must become interdimensional. And the world who doesn't see them must be claimed to nefariously be denying evidence. There's no "denial of evidence" to make when the "evidence" are only claims, testimonials, business like entertainment and tourism and misrepresented information.
We know that dinosaurs existed because we have ample evidence of it. We know that ancient aliens stories are likely false because there's no evidence for it, and we know that those who promote them even push pseudohistory to misattribute ancient civilizations, that's evidence of: a motive to deceive. We know that birds exist because there's plenty of evidence and we all see them all the time. We know that demons are unlikely to exist and that they are a product of the human imagination, we like entertaining fantasies and to deny death. We can diagnose psychiatric and neurological conditions that used to be misunderstood.
We know that the universe is old and large enough for life to sometimes occur in it, the reason we're here. But we also know that it's rare enough that two intelligent civilizations in space would be unlikely to ever discover eachother. The Fermi Paradox...
So as a conspiracy theorist, you attack scapegoats, accusing them of nefarious activity and of hiding evidence. Evidence that never existed. So you're alienated and are promoting alienation.