Continuing with a response to the TERFs in the OP:
For a group that claims that the existence of infertile women means that female can’t be defined, they sure spend a lot of time complaining about how they can’t get pregnant
No, that’s a misrepresentation. What transfolk and allies are actually saying is that you can’t define ‘female’ or ‘male’ solely by people’s reproductive capability, because there are even cis women and men who are naturally incapable of producing viable eggs or sperm, or even any at all. And you wouldn’t exclude them, now would you?
Of course you wouldn’t. And many of you are aware of this problem, so you expand the definition in such intricate ways as to specifically exclude trans people and avoid the whole problem with classifying intersex people according to their chromosomes (that is, when you don’t just say that they don’t count because they’re an exception or have a disorder).
Also, we do define ‘female’ (and ‘male’). We just do it in a way you don’t like.
Finally, you’re comparing apples and oranges. One’s desire to want to get pregnant doesn’t have much to do with how we define ‘female’. It may have to do with having a female gender identity, but one doesn’t need to have a strict definition of what the term ‘female’ means in order to have that internal sense of self.
Unlike TERFs, most people don’t have an anal-retentive, obsessive focus on semantics and the exact definitions of words, without which the entire world will supposedly fall apart.
( RusticTroglodyte )
It actually delights me that they so desperately want something they can't have. It makes me so happy to know they're suffering bc of it. Die mad, scrotes
You enjoy the pain and suffering of other people? We have some words for that, you know.
Sadism. Cruelty. Evil.
( Wsbfom01 )
Their desire to be pregnant comes from a fetish, not a sense of nurture or care for children.
No. See the link in my post above. The link’s content has to do with my personal feelings, but many other trans women have similar ones.
( TheChaliceIsMightier )
Babe wake up a new sticker idea just dropped
TWAW - trans women are wankers
You’re so clever. Here, have a cookie.
( Understanderson )
Oh my god, this is just soooooo creepy. I hate that we're not allowed to notice how creepy it is!
I could make a dig at how you happened to not only notice, but write about what you’re “not allowed to” notice… but I get what you mean. You can’t say everything you want in places other than Ovarit and the like. Such a huge tragedy.
But even that isn’t true. There’s a whole cottage industry on the right wing that lives for this shit. An entire media ecosystem who have this as their bread and butter. ‘Gender critical’ views are not only acceptable, but even welcome in many places. Hell, in the UK, you’re effectively the mainstream now.
( MaryDyer )
Why do you feel like less of a woman, boys? You’ve made it pretty clear that “woman” is meaningless and is merely a nebulous feeling.
Just because we see gender identity as key and it happens to be a feeling, or better said an internal sense of self, doesn’t mean that “woman” is meaningless. At all.
Why be so butthurt over not being able to get pregnant, when it’s apparently “bioessentialist” to include reproductive capacity in any form in a definition of woman? Hell, even in a definition of female? That’s right - you people have done your damndest to erase any mention of sex from the definition of female.
Reproductive capacity matters in relation to one’s bodily configuration, in medical settings. And there you will find various ones: cis women, cis men, but also variations in the form of people who hormonally transitioned and don’t have entirely the same sexual characteristics anymore.
The problem is that you want to define ‘woman’ (and ‘man’) SOLELY according to reproductive capacity, with the deliberate specific aim of excluding and socially erasing trans and nonbinary people. And that IS very much bio-essentialist.
Hell, bio-essentialism is the very core of TERF / GC ideology — it defines you, it’s all you have, it’s your solution to everything!
Unlike the feminists of old, you explicitly and vehemently believe that “biology is destiny”.
We, on the other hand, recognize that most of the time, gendered treatment and recognition of people is social in nature. Nearly all of the time, ‘woman’ and ‘man’ are social categories; as I said, reproductive questions tend to only come up in a medical setting or in relation to medical matters.
And in a social setting, which is most of our lives (by far!), we trans people often can and do function as members of the social category associated with our gender identity (rather than our natal sex). Trans women as women, trans men as men.
Yet here you are blowing snot because you can’t get pregnant. Why would you do such a thing? You’ve ensured that reproductive anatomy and biology have been uncoupled from woman, to the point that infertile females are likened to full on, reproductively-healthy males.
Now you seem to be…backtracking? Why? Is it because you know, despite what rhetoric you spread, that infertile women of a certain age are an anomaly, and you want to be a typical woman? Oh how sad for you. 😢
You are ignorant and arrogant, you don’t listen when you absolutely could (because we keep giving you answers to your dishonest questions), you throw around insults like schoolkids, and you have no empathy for those different than you.
There is no “backtracking”. There is only your refusal to think outside your narrow box (also known as ideological zealotry), and your lack of imagination when it comes to the lived realities of other people (in other words, lack of empathy).
But you are incapable of moving past that. You’ll spend your life limited to your petty schadenfreude and mocking people and things you refuse to understand. Now that is *actually* sad.