Radical trans theorists believe that anyone can be any sex or gender they declare, and that reality is not chained to any objective evidence and that sex and gender can change at any time.
Where are these radical trans theorists? Are they in the room with us?
If by that you meant “the mainstream of trans people”, then the only thing I’ll say to that is: No.
Radical feminists (and others) believe people are conceived as one of two sexes through a genetic process, and that sex cannot change in humans, and that sex is an objectively observable trait of organisms.
How nice of you to couch it in loaded terms of “just science, ma’am”, while painting the opposition as unreasonable and unscientific by default.
Then there are people who have declared themselves a reasonable middle ground between these two extremes. They believe that maybe sex isn’t changeable but if certain individuals meet standards of secondary sex characteristic manipulation (or if they put in significant enough effort in doing so) they should be treated as if they have changed sex, legally and socially.
“Manipulation.” Again with the loaded terms.
This is the fallacy of the Golden Mean.
No, this is the fallacy of “I’m making shit up in order to paint a skewed picture where my pet view is Obviously Rational and Scientific, while my opponents are Radical Theorists Who Deny Science (also, look at the strawman I made of them!)”.
No one can change sex, ever, and people who pretend that others have changed sex are lying and being unreasonable.
Not only is the enemy pretending, they are also lying! And being unreasonable! And are wrong, by definition! Because I say so, and what I say is science, which is right, because science is right!
In English we have third person pronouns based on sex. It might be awkward to refer to a woman who has done a great job disguising herself as a man with female pronouns, but to do otherwise would be creating a false impression. Some people do it out of social pressure… guess what, that’s what the story The Emperor’s New Clothes is about!
In the story The Emperor’s New Clothes, the crowd of people who see that the Emperor is stark bollocks naked but pretend they see his robe are not a reasonable position between the lying merchants and the child who shouts out “He’s naked!” The child is correct.
Picture the following, if you will.
There's a naked woman, for some reason. A crowd of people see her and keep saying how that’s a man, it’s so obvious that it’s a man! Doesn’t he look so very manly? SIR!
A high-pitched and serious-browed man, let’s call him “Ben Shapiro”, says that it is only Factual and Logical that she is a man. Realizing he had said ‘she’, he quickly corrects it to ‘he’.
A proud but miserable-looking woman, let’s call her “Joanne Kathleen Rowling”, nods sagely and says that the truth is obvious — chromosomes and gametes do not lie, unlike this dangerous male.
Murmurs of “Hear, hear!” are heard, as Ms Stock and Mr Walsh and Mrs Forstater and all the other concerned citizens agree that before them obviously stands a man, while Mr Musk — in a cloud of musky, smoky haze — chuckles, his laugh sounding much like the grunt of a pig. His eyes glassy, Mr Musk completed the scene with a drawn-out exclamation of “Duuuuuudeee.”
Meanwhile, a child observes, confused. It is obvious to him that the naked woman is very much a woman in every way, up to and including not having a peepee. Not understanding why the crowd of adults is loudly pretending otherwise, he blurts out that she’s a woman.
But in this tale, no truth is unveiled and no realization is to be had, because the townsfolk are gender-critical, and therefore their belief is stronger than the truth before their eyes… and the child’s lack of conviction shows that he must be brainwashed!