( stickyleaves )
A smart feminist academic friend still believes in gender theory, I think because:
-being a successful academic is super important to her identity and so she doesnāt want to die on that hill if it risks her career. I think this is a subconscious choice- she doesnāt want to dig into TERF-y things lest it shake the foundations, deep down I think she has some doubts
āEveryone who disagrees with me is greedy, stupid, malicious, pretending or in denialā, part 654254.
deep down I think she has some doubts (she used to talk about these to me a decade ago, now she wont acknowledge the doubts)
Or maybe, you know, she got to learn more and meet some trans people, and her doubts were laid to rest. Just a thought.
-sheās got your typical levels of self-doubt/imposter syndrome so is willing to assume that all the other smart lefties who are really into trans stuff must be right
You seem to hold your friendās intellect in really high regard! (/s)
Also, speaking as someone who has felt plenty of self-doubt and had imposter syndrome about a number of things, I can say thatās not how it works. We donāt just blindly defer to some authority; if anything, our self-doubt makes us feel doubt toward such very convinced people, too. When youāre prone to doubting your views, other peopleās firmness of views and their refusal to consider the alternatives may actually read like zealotry and closed-mindedness.
-she moves in hip, āqueerā circles and at least one close friend of hers has gone from lesbian to supposedly NB or trans. Itās much more convenient to believe her good friend is earnestly living their best life and fighting the good fight than that theyāre an idiot in this very important way.
You donāt even know if that close friend is NB or trans, as you yourself admit! Yet youāre oh-so-comfortable declaring said person to be an idiot, and assuming that their life is not truly good, or that theyāre not fighting for something worthwhile.
And of course you also derisively put āqueerā in quote marks, dismissing those people as a mere hip phenomenon.
Well, @stickyleaves, even from this single post you come off as a GIGANTIC asshole. Incredibly smug, arrogant, dismissive as well as outright belittling and patronizing toward the academic whom you call āfriendā.
None of this excuses any of it, but I think this is where her head is at. I wasnāt in the cool club enough to peak her yet, but I think she will get there.
And youāre proselytizing the gender-critical religion, because of course you are. Ready to pounce on any perceived weakness, any opening or moment of self-doubt, to convert the unbeliever woman into your one true cult.
At least I have a bit of hope that your missionary work will fail, given that people might notice the smarm dripping from you like thick ooze.